Karen Tuttle: Viola Playing Posture and Stance

Karen Tuttle was one of the most notable viola pedagogues and really revolutionized how many violists play without pain. To become a better teacher and performer, I’m going to go through the book The Karen Tuttle Legacy chapter by chapter and discuss her teachings and offer my own insights.

Today we’re starting with Karen Tuttle’s philosophies on viola playing posture and stance.

Watch the Video

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase from one of these links, I’ll make a small commission. Thank you for supporting my free content!

The book I’m pulling quotes from is The Karen Tuttle Legacy by Jeffry Irvine, Kim Kashkashian, Michelle LaCourse, Lynne Ramsey, Karen Ritscher, and Carol Rodland, edited by Alex Teploff.

The authors are six violists who were students of hers. In the book, they go through different aspects of technique and talk about Karen Tuttle’s philosophy and the way that she taught them those techniques with great descriptions and exercises.If you’re interested in becoming a better viola player, would like to know more about Karen Tuttle, or need some ideas of ways that you can explain things to your students, please continue watching and consider purchasing this book because it is really, really fantastic.

Today we’re going to go over the first technique chapter which is on stance: how you should lay out your body and hold the viola.

Plant Your Feet

In general, Karen Tuttle said to plant your feet and root through them. That is how you ground yourself and feel very supported. She also recommended feeling a lot of relaxation in your body. Not a lack of energy, but none of your muscles are working too hard. They’re not tense; they’re relaxed at their core to support everything that you need to do.

Stack Your Vertebrae

Kim Kashkashian has an excellent bullet point list of all the things that you should consider in your stance.

The first category is body.

She says, “Line up your body to create a vertical spring coil. The knees go over the balls of your feet. The hips over the heels of the feet. The pelvic bones centered over the arch of the feet. The ribs sit on the pelvis. The collar bones and shoulder blades sit on the waist. The jaw joint lines up with the collar bone.”

So, that means that our head is not extended forward or backward. Instead, it’s basically just straight. Think of everything shoulders and below coming down and your neck sort of coming up. That should basically put everything in alignment.

For stance, she says, “keep your head facing forward, a talking posture. Because when you turn your head to look at the fingerboard, your neck, shoulder, and chest muscles are contracted.” Imagine if you had to walk around with your head turned to one side all day every day. You would get so sore! Now, picture yourself playing viola like that. It would still make you sore from hours and hours of playing. So, keep everything facing forward, level, and aligned naturally.

Kashkashian reminds us that “all joints, including the neck and shoulder blades, should be independent and freely mobile without clenching and with minimal use of muscle power.” We don’t want to exert any extra energy than we absolutely need because viola playing is very intense and very physical. Keep everything in a neutral relaxation and only expend as much energy as you need, using gravity and the weight of your arm as leverage.

“Let gravity, leverage, and balance work for you. Contraction will inhibit this natural power.” We also want to think of equal and opposite reactions. “Absorb the impact of your motion in order to stay pliant so that every motion you generate is preceded and ended by relaxation.” So when you exert energy or muscles, you feel it rebound with with relaxation.

Holding the Instrument

Michelle LaCourse, one of Karen Tuttle’s students and a violist that I took a master class with, says, “The instrument is not held or gripped, but balanced like a teeter totter. The left shoulder never raises or pushes up, but passively accepts and supports the weight of the viola. The neck is never contracted nor the head turned to the side but nose and naval both faced forward or nose aligned with sternum.”

We always want to bring the viola to us. We never want to come to the viola. I teach that to all of my string students whether they play violin or viola. The natural weight of our head keeps the viola in place.

The instrument should sit solidly around our collar bone or on our shoulder. Then just the natural weight of our head is going to keep it in place. I don’t want to use the word clamp because that makes us think tension and locking muscles, but between our shoulder or collar bone and our chin with natural weight from our head, we’ll create a shape that surrounds the viola and keeps it in place.

We never want to lift with our left hand or feel like that is what’s holding it. It’s sort of all three points of contact working together to keep the viola in place. The left hand just ensures that the scroll doesn’t fall down, and really, simple gravity against our hand is what does that.

Energy

Carol Rodland says, “Fundamental to Karen Tuttle’s approach to playing the viola is the idea that our entire bodies, not just our violas, must experience and channel resonance while we play. This is achieved by cultivating physical ease and efficiency of movement in conjunction with healthy posture and awareness of the breath, energy flow, and presence in space. All of this has a profound effect on senority and joyful music making.”

If you’ve done the ragdoll pose in yoga where you bend at your hips while standing and dangle your upper body towards the ground, as you gradually begin to stand back up, the yoga instructor will say something along the lines of, “imagine lining up your feet stacking your hips above them, and each vertebrae lines up nice and straight one at a time.” You come up to a full standing posture with little to no tension. That feels very, very similar to the feeling that Karen Tuttle was describing.

Of course, with relaxation, knees are bent, but you’re planting your feet into the ground for that really grounded, energetic, but relaxed stance. Rooting into the floor with your feet, feeling the top part of your body really stacking up and lining up above your core is going to create a very powerful stance. You can do a lot in this stance! You could fight someone like this and not lose your footing. You can play the viola like this and you’re going to feel like a very powerful person, and it’s going to lead less to less tension as well.


I hope this overview helps you set up your viola playing in a very healthy, powerful way. This is essentially how I like to think of things, anyway but I love reading the violists’ writing on what exactly Karen Tuttle said because they’re great teaching phrases and they get a reaction out of students.

Stay tuned for more videos and blog posts going through this book and discussing Karen Tuttle’s teachings! Next time, we’ll talk about general left hand concepts and finger action.

Let me know your thoughts on Karen Tuttle’s viola playing posture and stance philosophy and my takes below. I’d love to hear from you!

Elizabeth


Discover more from Life from the Viola Section

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Similar Posts